Last verified: November 2026
What SOC 2 actually asks of your incident response and recovery testing
What a SOC 2 examination asks of incident response and recovery testing, and what it doesn't. Why the Trust Services Criteria never name a tabletop exercise, where scenario-based testing does appear, how the Availability category changes the picture, what a Type 2 auditor looks for, and the 2027 criteria now in draft.
SOC 2
If your company sells to other businesses, a customer has probably asked for your SOC 2 report. Somewhere along the way you may have been told SOC 2 requires an annual tabletop exercise.
It doesn't. SOC 2 is an examination of your controls by a CPA firm, measured against the AICPA's Trust Services Criteria. **No criterion names a tabletop exercise, a simulation or a testing interval.**¹
What the criteria do expect is more useful than a calendar entry. Every SOC 2 covers how you respond to incidents and recover from them, and the AICPA's guidance for those criteria describes periodic, scenario-based testing of your recovery plans and evaluating how well your response worked.¹ That is the case for exercising, and the second half of this guide makes it. The first half is what the criteria actually say.
How to read this guide. The Trust Services Criteria are published by the AICPA. Where we describe what a criterion or point of focus asks for, that is our characterisation, in our own words, and we cite criterion numbers so you can find the text yourself. The AICPA publishes the criteria free with registration. If you are preparing for an examination, your auditor's reading is the one that counts.
Who this applies to
A SOC 2 report is an attestation, not a certification. An independent CPA examines a service organization's system and controls and reports on them against the Trust Services Criteria.² Customers ask for one to judge whether they can trust you with their data or their operations.
| Report | What the auditor opines on |
|---|---|
| Type 1 | Your system description, and whether your controls are suitably designed, as of one date² |
| Type 2 | Everything in a Type 1, plus whether the controls operated effectively over a period, with the auditor's tests and results² |
SOC 2 is voluntary. No law requires it. Your customers' contracts often do.
Categories: Security is always in scope
The criteria are grouped into five categories: Security, Availability, Processing Integrity, Confidentiality and Privacy.¹ Security, also called the common criteria, is in every SOC 2 report. The other four are included when you and your customers choose them.
This matters for testing. The incident and recovery criteria sit in Security, so they apply to every report. The criterion that explicitly asks for tested recovery plans sits in Availability, so it applies only if Availability is in scope.
Requirements at a glance
| What the criteria ask, in substance | Where | Category | Exercise or test named? |
|---|---|---|---|
| Evaluate security events to decide whether they are failures, and act on them | CC7.3¹ | Security | No |
| Respond to incidents through a defined incident-response program that understands, contains, remediates and communicates | CC7.4¹ | Security | No. Guidance asks you to evaluate the effectiveness of your response |
| Identify, develop and carry out activities to recover from incidents | CC7.5¹ | Security | Guidance describes periodic, scenario-based recovery testing |
| Plan risk mitigation for business disruptions | CC9.1¹ | Security | No |
| Environmental protections, backups and recovery infrastructure | A1.2¹ | Availability | No |
| Test recovery plan procedures that support system recovery | A1.3¹ | Availability | Yes, in the criterion itself. Form and frequency not specified |
Our summary, not the AICPA's wording. Criterion numbers from the 2017 Trust Services Criteria, with points of focus revised in 2022. As of November 2026.
Criteria and points of focus: what binds
Each criterion is followed by points of focus: characteristics the AICPA considers important for meeting it. They are not requirements. Using the criteria does not require an assessment of whether each point of focus is addressed, and you can tailor them or use others that fit your organization.¹ Your auditor tests the controls you describe against the criterion.
So "SOC 2 requires X" is usually half a sentence. The criterion asks for an outcome. The points of focus describe what a strong control tends to include. Your auditor decides whether your controls meet the criterion.
SOC 2 is not an exercise standard
CC7.4 asks for an incident-response program, not a rehearsal of it. In substance it expects defined roles, containment, remediation and communication protocols.¹ Two of its points of focus look backward: periodically evaluating whether your incident-response activities are designed effectively, and periodically reviewing incidents for patterns and root causes.¹ Neither names an exercise. Both are much easier to show when your team has worked through an incident recently.
CC7.5 is where testing appears. Its points of focus include improving response and recovery procedures from what you learn, and incident-recovery plan testing. In substance, that testing is periodic, built on scenarios chosen for how likely and how severe the threats are, considers system components across the organization, includes the loss of key people, and feeds the results back into your resilience posture and continuity plans.¹
A1.3 makes testing a criterion, for reports that include Availability. It asks you to test the recovery plan procedures that support system recovery.¹ Its points of focus describe business continuity plan testing that checks you can respond to, recover from and resume operations through significant disruptions. It uses the same four elements, with vendors added, plus testing that backup data is complete and intact.¹
What none of them set: the form of the test, who runs it, or how often. A walkthrough, a tabletop, a technical failover and a full simulation can each be valid, depending on what you are testing.
What a Type 2 examination looks at
In a Type 2, the auditor tests whether your controls operated over the whole period, often six or twelve months.² For incident response and recovery, that typically means evidence, not intentions:
- A plan that was used. A dated record that the incident-response or recovery plan was tested or invoked during the period.
- Who took part. Roles named in the plan showing up in the test.
- What was found. Findings, decisions and gaps, written down at the time.
- What changed. Plan or control updates that trace back to those findings.
A test that happened but left no record is hard to evidence. A record that shows nothing changed raises the question of what the test was for.
Why exercise anyway: what these criteria actually ask of you
The criteria ask you to evaluate whether your response was effective and to improve your procedures from what you learn.¹ Both need material to work with. A real incident provides it, but you can't schedule one, and a quiet year leaves those points of focus with nothing to show.
An exercise is the incident you can schedule. It puts your incident-response program under realistic pressure, on your timeline, with an evaluation built in.
The scenario guidance describes a good exercise. Scenarios chosen for likelihood and severity, components from across the organization, key people unavailable, and results fed back into the plan.¹ That is also a fair description of an exercise that teaches you something.
A script that confirms the plan gives the evaluation nothing. When the next inject arrives on schedule whatever the team just decided, the exercise tests the script, not the response. Injects that follow the room's decisions keep testing the plan after its first step holds.
The 2027 criteria are in draft
On October 28, 2026 the AICPA proposed revised Trust Services Criteria for public comment, open until January 15, 2027. If adopted, they would apply to engagements beginning on or after December 31, 2027, with early adoption allowed. The draft also adds points of focus on AI risk.³
Published summaries of the draft describe the incident criteria CC7.2 to CC7.5 being consolidated into a single incident-response criterion, and a new Availability criterion on resilience capabilities.⁴ Criterion numbers on this page will change. The underlying expectation, a working response program you can show evidence for, is unlikely to.
Where the criteria are deliberately open
- No frequency. "Periodic" is not defined. Your policy sets the interval, and your auditor tests that you kept to it.
- No format. Tabletop, functional test and technical failover are all open to you, as long as the test fits what you claim it tests.
- No facilitator rules. Internal and external facilitators are both acceptable.
- Scope is yours to choose. Whether Availability is in your report is a decision you make with your customers, and it changes whether A1.3 applies.
What Crewcible produces that maps to it
Crewcible is built for the exercise itself: designing it, running it, and capturing what came out of it. Three outputs line up against what a SOC 2 auditor asks to see.
The exercise. Realistic incident and recovery scenarios built in hours, from the Global Library, from your own design, or drafted with AI around your threats and your people. They are designed to support the incident-response and recovery testing described on this page.
The record. Crewcible captures each decision and the reasoning behind it, per participant and per inject, as the exercise runs. What you hand an auditor is a dated record rather than a recollection written up a week later.
The improvement plan. Findings come out of the exercise as an after-action report and an improvement plan, so the line from test to plan change is on paper.
The facilitator decides what gets released and when, so the judgment stays with your people. AI enabled, human led.
Crewcible is built by experts who have supported crisis situations and exercises in the world's largest organizations.
References current as of November 2026. This guide is scheduled for re-verification by May 2027, or sooner if the 2027 criteria are adopted.
¹ AICPA Assurance Services Executive Committee, 2017 Trust Services Criteria for Security, Availability, Processing Integrity, Confidentiality, and Privacy (with Revised Points of Focus, 2022). Free with AICPA registration. Criteria CC7.3 to CC7.5, CC9.1, A1.2 and A1.3, and the introduction on points of focus.
² Journal of Accountancy, The three faces of SOC, June 2016.
³ Journal of Accountancy, AICPA proposes improvements to SOC 2 trust services criteria, October 28, 2026.
⁴ Schellman, SOC 2 is getting an update: what the revised Trust Services Criteria mean for your organization. A summary of the exposure draft by an audit firm; check against the final criteria when published.